Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

4 Comments

  1. Ms. Lights introduced her conversation with a brief discussion of our species’ tribalism, why objective evaluation of situations or facts are not nearly as important as influencing other members of the group, and reaching consensus and agreement. Because in our early development, if you were voted off the island, you would die.

    That fear remains: it’s origins and consequences are explored by Elizabeth Kolbert in Why facts don’t change our minds. (New Yorker, Feb 2017)

    Even after the evidence for their beliefs has been totally refuted, people fail to make appropriate revisions in those beliefs…

    Humans’ biggest advantage over other species is our ability to cooperate… Reason developed not to enable us to solve abstract, logical problems or even to help us draw conclusions from unfamiliar data; rather, it developed to resolve the problems posed by living in collaborative groups…

    If reason were designed to generate sound judgments, then it’s hard to conceive of a more serious design flaw than confirmation bias. Humans aren’t randomly credulous. Presented with someone else’s argument, we’re quite adept at spotting the weaknesses. Almost invariably, the positions we’re blind about are our own.

    Good article. I’m heartened that Zion Lights has accepted the challenge head-on.

  2. Thanks to Rod and Zion Lights for the fine presentation.

    So this nuclear power thing is actually a PR problem. It is a case of needing to be sold. It’s more about feelings than facts and figures.

    My father told me years ago that you can sell a product by generating a demand. If people have a demand for nuclear plants, the supply will follow.

    The Simpsons were mentioned as being a great influence on all of those environmentalists. Apparently, there is power in Homer and Blinky. It’s hard to fight this icon of Americana.

    However, like the Lincoln Project, I think a few well placed TV commercials would go a long way. I’m an old guy and have a couple of retro commercial ideas. I hope there is some appreciation for these silly ideas.

    1) There is a guy who looks like the Marlboro man. There is no greater symbol of Americana than the American cowboy. The Grand Canyon Suite is playing. The ad starts in black and white. Our Marlboro man cowboy is crushing a pack of smokes and tossing them in the trash. “I thought I got rid of these,” He declares in a low Western drawl. He goes on to say, “I like fresh air now.”The camera pulls out to show him and his horse in a meadow with hyperbolic cooling towers. The ad makes a transition from the black and white to a Kodachrome like color. There are colorful flowers growing around the cooling towers. The next shot is of our Marlboro man character riding off into the sunset and saying, “My horse likes the fresh air too.” Then there is the symbol of the atom with a few electrons spinning around it. It morphs into a 1970s yellow smiley face and the ad is over.

    The real Marlboro man died of lung cancer. He would have been better doing nuke ads.

    2) This ad also starts in black and white. The song, “As Time Goes By,” is playing. An actor and actress are dressed up like Humphrey Bogart and Ingrid Bergman are kissing in front of a nuclear plant. The actress turns to the actor and says, “Rick! Thank you for taking me here. I love the fresh air.” The same effect is then used with the picture becoming colorized. This time when the effect is applied it is similar to the look as applied to old black and white movies. Again, the atom symbol is shown with the morphing effect into the 1970s smiley face.

    Mr. Bogart died of Cancer.

    Anyway, it’s just a thought.

  3. Glad to have you aboard Ms. Lights. I guess there is reason to be hopeful… I chose nuclear power to be my life’s work after a similar awakening. No doubt I speak for many contributors when I say we will back you so long as you stay on message. A good spokesperson is a priceless.

Similar Posts

  • Winning a debate in Sydney – We have seen the future and it’s nuclear

    Ben Heard of Decarbonise SA shared a teaser video clip from a recent Big Ideas debate titled We’ve seen the future and it’s nuclear. In this clip, Ben spends his allotted 9 minutes telling people how he became convinced that the only path to an abundant, reliable future energy supply system that minimizes CO2 and…

  • Atomic Show #230 – Alex Epstein, The Moral Case for Fossil Fuels

    Alex Epstein, the founder of the Center for Industrial Progress, recently published The Moral Case for Fossil Fuels. Trained as a philosopher, Alex describes himself as anti-pollution but pro-development. He believes that the standard of value for any development or technology should be its impact for human beings and that the green standard of non-impact…

  • Atomic Show #186 – SMRs, Climate Change, and Natural Gas Competition

    On the evening of July 29, 2012, Suzy Hobbs-Baker, Director of the Nuclear Literacy Project and founder of PopAtomic Studios, Dan Yurman, who blogs at Idaho Samizdat and writes for Fuel Cycle Week and the ANS Nuclear Cafe, Margaret Harding, an independent nuclear energy consultant who blogs at 4 Factor Consulting, and Cal Abel, a…

  • European Climate Foundation Has a Dangerous Blind Spot Regarding Nuclear Energy

    The European Energy Review (free subscription required) recently published an interview with Arne Mogren, Director of the Power Programme of the European Climate Foundation (ECF) titled Everyone agrees on where we need to be in 2050, but not on how to get there. The ECF is billed as one of the more influential climate lobby…

  • Analogy – Steroids & Home Runs vs CO2 & Extreme Weather

    I like the above video, though I would make a few changes if I could draw. For example, I would more carefully choose dimensions in the scene that shows the earth surrounded by what is apparently supposed to be the atmosphere. The earth’s diameter is roughly 8,000 miles, but its atmosphere is only a few…

  • Put Nuclear Power in your stockings

    I know, I am like one of those people who are still sending out Christmas cards in January. However, I just ran across this brief little video that I thought was worth sharing. The good news, bad news story is that Amazon lists Nuclear Power: How a Nuclear Power Plant Really Works as temporarily sold…