11 Comments

  1. Many issues need to be fixed with the current Yucca plan IF it goes forward. First, of course, is the ridiculous rad levels. The EPA standards need to be scrapped and realistic standards need to be used.

    But the most significant design criteria to change is allow the fuel to be retrievable. Not buried for 10,000+ years. That is the non-proliferation side having way too much sway on the game plan. The fuel is valuable now and will be even more valuable in the future. Don’t create artificial barriers for future generations.

  2. “Tuesday’s (Executive Order) initiates a review of the Clean Power Plan, rescinds the moratorium on coal mining on US federal lands and urges federal agencies to “identify all regulations, all rules, all policies … that serve as obstacles and impediments to American energy independence…”

  3. “Before any large scale shipments can begin, there will be a need for a specialized rail line that can deliver large used fuel transportation casks to the repository; a decade ago the estimated cost for that system was greater than $3 billion.”

    How many miles long would this railroad be? 100 miles?

    I found a map of proposed routes:

    http://www.yuccamountain.org/map06.gif

    A hundred miles would give $30,000,000 / mile. Why would this railroad have to be engineered beyond any railroad that carries other hazardous waste, i.e. chemicals? I see tank cars on railroads all of the time carrying bad stuff. Wouldn’t this cargo actually be safer than most? It is heavy stuff that won’t blow away in the wind. I presume they will use similar casks to those designed years ago that withstand high impacts.

    Would they be using golden spikes?

    With low natural gas prices, unnecessary requirements should be stripped from nuclear.

  4. It’s a fair question, Eino. SNF fuel casks are designed for conventional rail transport, having been thoroughly tested and used without incident for that purpose for fifty years.

    Still, one must allow the possibility that a combined freight manifest of SNF casks sandwiched between multiple tanker cars of diesel interleaved with flats of fertilizer might derail and catch fire in a hypothetical tunnel, much like the 2001 Howard Street train tunnel fire in Baltimore. 😮

  5. Wow.
    If taken literally, that would shake up a LOT of long-established regulations, rules and policies.
    For example, the Linear No Threshold assumption (as it is incorporated into regulations, rules and policies) certainly serves as an obstacle and impediment to American energy independence.

  6. The BTU content of a “spent” fuel assembly from a light water reactor is worth 4 times its weight in gold at current natural gas prices. Moving the fuel from all corners of the country and burying it is a huge waste of resources.

  7. There’s a very large educational piece on spent fuel canisters that would need to be taught to the masses on why safe transportation is essentially a non-issue. Too many people, including the politicians, are flat out ignorant on the science behind the robustness of these casks. My bigger issue with this whole thing is, why is it okay to not follow the law? In our line of business, if I deliberately choose to violate procedure, I can go to Federal prison. Procedures are the law in nuclear power operations. Why is it okay for our “leaders” in this country to violate the law?

  8. Much, much more could be done to support nuclear power in America by streamlining regulations and supporting advanced nuclear reactors than reopening Yucca mountain. Heck, Generation IV reactors can do Yucca mountain’s job for it. Nuclear batteries are being designed that feed directly off of nuclear radiation

    http://www.atlasenergysystems.org/technology.html

    I would like to see the Trump administration look into developing regulatory support for advanced nuclear reactors and hopefully rescind unnecessary regulations like the baseless Linear No Threshold.

  9. The long term solution for the spent fuel produced from commercial reactors in the US is to recycle its fertile and fissile uranium content and its fissile plutonium content.

    Demonstrating that this can be safely and continuously done– sustainably and economically– for even a tiny portion of the spent fuel that the US has accumulated over the decades would be a game changer for the industry, IMO.

    Marcel

  10. If it must be buried, use salt domes. The facility near Carlsbad, NM, will do.

Comments are closed.

Similar Posts

  • Fission Fans Should Unite – Target Of Interest Is Fossil Fuel Market Share

    I’ve spent a fair amount of time during the past few days trying to convince people who promote only certain types of nuclear fission technologies that they are engaging in the wrong battle. They are failing to recognize that all forms of fission take advantage of the incredible energy density found in atomic nuclei to…

  • Atomic Show #149 – Pro Nuclear Bloggers Reaction to SOTU Address

    During the 2010 State of the Union Address, President Obama took the handcuffs off of the nuclear industry revival when he said: But to create more of these clean energy jobs, we need more production, more efficiency, more incentives. And that means building a new generation of safe, clean nuclear power plants in this country….

  • Trump Budget Blueprint For DOE Will Revive Yucca Conflict. Does Little To Enable Nuclear

    The first few words of the first bullet in the Department of Energy’s (DOE) section of the Trump Administration’s Budget Blueprint seem purposely chose to instigate maximum conflict. Provides $120 million to restart licensing activities for the Yucca Mountain nuclear waste repository This phrase, describing a spending item that represents just 0.4% of a $28…

  • Anti abundance is common link between anti GMO and anti nuclear

    A couple of days ago, Mark Lynas, author of The God Species, gave an impassioned speech to the Oxford Farming Conference during which he apologized profusely for his former actions against genetically modified organisms (GMO). He stated that he now deeply regretted his participation in organized protests and direct actions to destroy experimental crops. He…

  • House committee report sharply critical of passive aggressive “decision” on Yucca

    The US House of Representatives Committee on Science, Space and Technology has released a report of its findings on the politically motivated budgetary maneuvers that NRC Chairman Gregory Jaczko employed to starve his own staff of the funds required to complete their legally mandated review of the DOE Yucca Mountain repository application. He took that…

  • Nuclear advocacy opportunity in Vermont – November 30

    This is a Public Service Announcement. November 30 Film and Panel at the Gund Institute The Energy Education Project of the Ethan Allen Institute has two members of our Board of Advisors on the panel at an event sponsored by the Gund Institute at University of Vermont (UVM). The film and panel start at 4…