Michael Shellenberger smiling in a blue suit at Atomic Insights event.

3 Comments

  1. I suspect Constellation is getting little out of Blue Wave AI… The solution biases in power distribution/margin and reactivity in these core simulator ‘codes’ are manifestations of modeling/method limitations made for run time (runs fast). The BWR operators are generally locked into using the fuel vendors’ licensed, design of record, core simulator to do the design and monitoring work. The dominant vendor’s core simulator uses very old diffusion methods that ‘run fast’ and have been ‘good enough’ for at least two decades. Biases could be reduced with better methods like those developed by Studsvik, but generally are accommodated by additional design margin fat [biasing low] with the ‘bad code’. So, Blue Wave seems to be making a science project analyzing/reconciling relatively ‘bad answers’ with instrumentation that until recently was considered ‘calibrated’ when within 10% of a reference power distribution reconstructed from periodic (40 day) movable detector traces using the ‘bad code’. Like you said it’s heady, technical stuff and way more down in the weeds than typical for your blog. FWIW, the fuel vendor has for decades been using an ‘AI’ written by our BWXT colleague William E. Russell (Prometheus) to balance all the different design constraints with a best solution. Still, designers find the program hard to constrain and generally just do the design work themselves. My coworkers and I earn our livings this way.

  2. The New York State new build article would have had a lot of comments… My ask there would have been why build FOAK? I’d love to see little BWRs built, but think the ABWR or AP1000 would be better choices.

  3. Revised:

    WRT Blue Wave, the solution biases in core simulator ‘codes’ are manifestations of modeling/method limitations/compromises made for run time. Most BWR fleet operators are locked into using the fuel vendors’ licensed, design of record, core simulator to do the design, monitoring, and maneuvering work. The dominant vendor’s core simulator uses old diffusion methods that ‘run fast’ and have been ‘good enough’ for at least two decades. Biases could be reduced with better methods (COTS and in development), but are accommodated by additional design margin fat [biasing low]. Reload batch size is going to be what it’s going to be for a given cycle duration +/- 4 assemblies (~1%), with or without talent or AI; room for improvement is incremental at best.

    Blue Wave seems to be analyzing/reconciling relatively ‘bad answers’ with instrumentation. The instrumentation is considered calibrated/operable when readings are within 10% of a reference power distribution, reconstructed (splined) from periodic (40 day) movable detector traces, *using* the ‘bad code’. As you wrote, it’s heady, technical stuff and way more down in the weeds than typical for your blog. FWIW, the fuel vendor has for decades been using an ‘AI’ written by a former colleague (Prometheus) to balance all the different design constraints with a best solution. Still, designers find the program hard to constrain and generally just do the design work themselves.

Comments are closed.

Similar Posts

  • The Atomic Show #153 – Suzy Hobbs Founder PopAtomic.org

    Suzy Hobbs is a talented artist with a passion for atomic energy. She has created an organization of fellow artists whose mission is to create images that help people understand why there are intelligent, talented engineers, technicians, scientists and teachers who love the idea of using fission to replace fossil fuel combustion in as many…

  • The Atomic Show #047 – Atomic Batteries that last a very long time

    Atomic batteries can store thousands of times more energy per unit mass than chemical batteries – leading to very long lives in special applications One of our listeners – Bruno Garcia – asked us to talk about nuclear (atomic) batteries. These devices make use of the energy that radioactive isotopes emit on a continuous basis…

  • Atomic Show #318 – Brian Gitt, Business Development, Oklo

    Brian Gitt, the Business Development lead at Oklo, visited the Atomic Show to describe his employer’s business model and current prospects. Oklo is an advanced fission and fuel recycling company with an expansive vision for becoming a competitive clean energy supplier. It plans to provide heat and/or electricity as a service from a fleet of…

  • The Atomic Show #161 – Shoreham Documentary Project

    httpv://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y8CqdECzklI In early 2009 a recently graduated film student and a journalist who grew up on Long Island got together to produce a film about the Shoreham Nuclear Power Plant fiasco. Originally planned as a 10 minute YouTube video, the project grew to what might be a documentary lasting 100 minutes. Rod Adams and Gwyneth…

  • Atomic Show #325 – Marco Visscher – The Power of Nuclear

    After many years as an independent journalist with an antinuclear bent, Marco Visscher began questioning his long-held beliefs. He realized that the accepted alternatives to fossil fuel were not actually reducing fossil fuel use so much as they were limiting the rate at which it was increasing. He began acknowledging that nuclear energy was a…