6 Comments

  1. Re: “He is concerned about the way that so many people accept the conventional wisdom — which is so often promoted by people who are interested in selling more natural gas — that all we need for our future energy needs are various forms of renewable energy firmed up with “clean, cheap natural gas.”

    Why SHOULDN’T people feel that way when you hide nuclear’s virtues and advantages in a PR closet? Why must a NYC resident like me see more Puppy Rescue ads than _any_ extolling the benefits of Indian Point whom our esteemed governor can’t wait to take apart? I grit my teeth at the Gas Lady commercials but hey — they’re only doing the logical thing to get their word and product out — just like how now sterling BP Gulf did to get their impossibly soiled bacon out of the fire. No, I can’t blame the oil and gas companies a wilt for making themselves known to the world. It’s the nuclear “industry”/community/collective that hasn’t a clue about stroking and educating the public. Preach on more to the choir, folks! Or call Puppy Rescue to learn how it’s done — and funded!

    James Greenidge
    Queens NY

  2. “the benefits that we have developed along the way have far overwhelmed any cost increases.”

    What are these benefits? Do these benefits allow Southern Company to increase their profits from Vogtle 3-4? If the benefits directly impact the revenues that Southern can reap from the units they’re currently building, that’s wonderful. If these benefits are something else, like rebuilding an American supply chain that will benefit the next builder, the argument that Southern will reap great benefit from that makes far less sense.

  3. @Timothy Wyatt

    As explained in the quote, the benefits will allow Southern to charge customers less than expected over a long predicted operating period. As a rate-regulated, integrated electric utility, Southern’s chief benefit will come from keeping rates low and attracting new customers to its service territory over time.

    As Fanning mentioned in passing during his talk, Southern is negotiating for additional plants to take advantage of its investment in learning. He said they have to resolve “some vendor issues.”

  4. Well, since Georgia Power is suing Westinghouse and Stone & Webster for over $900M, those issues may take some time being resolved. I want the US nuclear sector to expand as much as anyone, but the performance of the Vogtle and Summer projects isn’t helping make that a reality.

  5. Perhaps the resolution of “vendor issues” will be to choose a different vendor.

  6. @FermiAged

    Changing vendors would eliminate all of the learning from the FOAK project. Better to learn to work together and to recognize that NRC has some responsibility for things that Southern has called “vendor issues.” Like many licensees, Southern mistakenly believes “you can’t fight city hall.”

Comments are closed.

Similar Posts

  • Atomic power to the people

    A couple of days ago, I came across an inspirational logo. I liked it so much that I contacted the person who had posted it on the Nukes page on Facebook. It was on a flyer announcing a series of talks about atomic energy at the Dallas Makerspace by a group called Atomic Energy Interest…

  • Learn more about internationalizing market for SMRs at 5th Annual SMR Summit

    Interest is growing in building right-sized reactors. In the relatively near future, there will be operating demonstration plants in China, Argentina, and Russia proving that the nuclear industry has learned that the one-size fits all model cannot work if the chosen size is in the range of 1,000 MWe. There simply are not enough customers…

  • Nuclear Infrastructure Council and Argonne teaming up for a trailblazing nuclear tech summit

    Interest in alternative nuclear energy technologies continues to strengthen, despite the challenging financial environment and despite the regulatory hurdles that need to be moved out of the way. Atomic energy innovators continue to be inspired by the technical promise of highly concentrated fuel, tiny waste stream and zero air pollution or CO2 production. The potential…

  • Energized by young nuclear enthusiasts

    Attending an ANS (American Nuclear Society) Student Conference is one of my favorite ways to reinforce my faith in humanity and to stoke my excitement about the future of nuclear energy. This year’s event, Dispelling Nuclear Myths – hosted by the ANS chapter at the University of Pittsburg – has been a wonderful addition to…

  • Broad Interest in Nukes, Especially SMRs, at National Clean Energy Week

    National Clean Energy Week was conceived in June by the Coalition of Responsible Energy Solutions. During July and August the organizers attracted partners, sponsors and speakers. They developed a week-long agenda and located venues for the expo, symposium and panels. Festivities began with a welcome reception for invited guests at Google’s Washington, D.C. office on…

  • Accelerator Driven System promoters are playing to irrational antinuclear fears

    By Ed Pheil I mentioned at the Thorium Energy Conference 2013 that accelerator driven systems (ADS) were likely to hurt the nuclear industry more than help it with the following discussion. The ADS proponents are justifying their participation, including with thorium, on the basis of two concepts that cater to the anti-nuclear crowd. A) ADS…