19 Comments

  1. Interesting article! I’m from Naples, FL and I had no idea that there was an oil reserve in the area. I can see people also protesting against oil drilling because the everglades are a massive wildlife refuge area with many endangered species.

  2. A good follow-up by the proceeds of Pandora would be to invite reps of all top environmental groups to a single forum and have a live webcast of their qualms about PP and nuclear energy to get it out exactly where they stand and won’t waver. Have them publically outright endorse/excuse oil and gas production and use over nuclear’s record. That’s what the public’s really missing here. There’s no fire of outrage in the belly to change because they’re clueless of nuclear’s true record and the opposition’s — which green groups don’t hawk.

    James Greenidge
    Queens NY

  3. Oil from Florida’s approximately 52 existing wells (2005) in 11 fields is rapidly drying up. I have no doubt theyll go for it eventually. The two sites in Florida are also being considered for fracking that are roughly I believe in the same area(s) you mentioned. Sunniland field in southwest Florida and the Jay field in the Panhandle.

    Century Oil is considering Florida oil fracking. I think N gas is still on the table as well rod.

    After development, accidents and contamination issues I am also very worried about subsidence. I think the issue has been grossly glossed over but is critical, as in Louisiana, and beyond the Mississippi delta regions.

  4. It’s a pity that The Oil Drum is going inactive.  It would be fascinating to get an essay on Floridian petro-geology and how drilling is going in the second round.

  5. If the oil companies are smart, they’ll “greenwash” the oil operation by building a few windmills to provide the power to pump the oil (and of course, diesel or methane backup generators for when the wind isn’t blowing, most of the time).

    I bet that would even pay them back – because, I may be wrong, but at current oil prices, I think even “expensive” wind power is considerably cheaper than oil? Why burn their product to pump the product, if they can use wind to do it part of the time, at least?

  6. Excellent point.  The same might work in the Athabasca area, if winds are strong there (they’re phenomenal in SK).  Excess electricity could be dumped to heaters to generate steam, displacing natural gas.

  7. On July 4th there was a protest in Naples for oil drilling that was about 1000 feet from homes ( http://www.fox4now.com/news/local/214340601.html )

    Im not sure if many of you are watching it but for a few days now the oil train story in Canada has been horrific if not all but ignored by the press. A train carrying oil (100 tons per car – 72 cars) broke free and derailed in Lac-Megantic, Quebec setting off explosions. 5 people are confirmed dead with 40 still missing. ( http://www.thestar.com/news/canada/2013/07/08/lac_megantic_quebec_train_derailment_site_still_too_hot_to_search_for_40_missing.html ).

  8. Actually its just starting to get press. After a few days. Fukushima was front and center for months, with every nut and quack giving “expert” assessments, and it had no casualties. This has several and with oil still burning in the sewers and headed towards water is also likely to be much more environmentally destructive as well.

  9. I know that it’s had major news time here in Canada (Calgary, Alberta).

    It’s big news here as we are pretty much a close to Pipeline Central as you can get.

  10. I hope most of the missing are staying with relatives Curtis. I was looking at the area on google earth and the reports say there was a live performance at the Musi-Cafe ( 5078 Frontenac, Lac-Mégantic ) which looks to be only about 100 meters from the bend in the railroad. Above it its a straight shot into town. I can see how the cars could slide in that direction. I hope people were able to get out in the confusion and navigate to safety.

  11. Did you see the pictures of the town pretty much leveled by that train explosion? It looks like Dresden after the firebombing. The whole place was burned out. And Fukushima did nothing like that, yet the press beat it to death. Here is a real-life disaster and tragedy just across our border and it gets essentially no coverage, but something 15,000 miles away with no damage beyond the plant boundaries was covered like white on rice.

  12. Not just that, but any number of refinery and chemical-plant explosions and train accidents have had more and worse casualties than the Fukushima meltdowns.

    This totally irrational fear of harmless things must be called what it is:  a rampant phobia.

  13. It got quite some press in France. At start the Asiana flight had more, but it’s starting to get big.

    That Musi-Cafe has been leveled. I hope people had a warning and time to escape, but I’m not convinced.

  14. Exactly the same Australia. No coverage for the first couple of days, but it’s getting several minutes coverage on television news and from half a page or so in newspapers now there are some personal anecdotes and some ‘facts’ starting to emerge. Hope for the best for the ~40 missing people.

  15. In the telegraph today there is a “Former Fukushima nuclear plant boss dies of cancer ” headline. Its irritating to me that even I didn’t think it through and immediately thought about the accident. That would be highly unlikely given the timeframe, exposure and lack of other evidence/cases.

    The article didn’t mention any high risk behavior Yoshida might have engaged in, like smoking so I didn’t think it was an issue. Of course after quickly checking I found that wasn’t likely the case:

    He recalled in the interview often passing out cigarettes to workers in a heavily used smoking room beside the bunker during the disaster and once joked: “We don’t have the US army fire trucks we need but at least we have got smokes.”

    Its kinda ironic with current safety that the smoking room over time is probably the most proven dangerous part of a nuclear plant.

  16. I have mixed feeling about the Oil Drum going inactive. On one hand I learned a lot from that site, but on the other hand there is way too much human hating going on in the comment section.

  17. Personally, I avoided the place the same way I avoid hanging out in lunatic asylums. Sure, you can learn a lot from the inmates, but you’re never sure which reality they’re talking about.

Comments are closed.

Similar Posts

  • Amory Lovins suggests additional areas of agreement between us

    Amory Lovins understands that high quality blogging requires interaction between the author and the people who take time to make comments. He actively engages with readers after he publishes posts on Forbes.com. He even visits here and engages on occasion. I admire that and enjoy the opportunity to spar with a famous person whose views…

  • Taking the bloom off of the nuclear rose

    Yesterday I came across a New York Times front page article from July 7, 1971 titled Nation’s Energy Crisis: Nuclear Future Looms. It is the second article in a three part article on the energy crisis that was capturing America’s attention in 1971 – two years before the Arab Oil Embargo. The discovery knocked me…

  • Kumi Naidoo of Greenpeace asks energy companies to shift from coal, oil, gas to clean energy

    On November 21, 2913, Democracy Now’s Amy Goodman interviewed Kumi Naidoo, the Executive Director of Greenpeace, in a segment titled Greenpeace: In Opposing Oil Drilling, Detained “Arctic 30” Are Standing Up for Planet’s 7 Billion. (There is a full transcript of the interview at the link provided.) The above embedded video above includes the interview…

  • Switch II Fission, the Sequel

    Last night I drove to Lexington, VA where the Washington and Lee sustainability program was hosting a screening of Switch (to a smarter future). There was a decent crowd; perhaps 100 or more students, faculty and townspeople. It is an impressive documentary, with inside views of facilities that people rarely see. It also does a…

  • Is Levy County nuclear plant too expensive to compete with natural gas?

    On Saturday, May 11, 2013, the Tampa Bay Times published a lengthy piece by Ivan Penn titled Levy nuclear plant more costly than a natural gas facility that uses a detailed analysis with substantial “error bars” around cost estimates to show that under nearly all scenarios considered, the two reactor installation that has been proposed…