• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About
  • Podcast
  • Archives
  • Links

Atomic Insights

Atomic energy technology, politics, and perceptions from a nuclear energy insider who served as a US nuclear submarine engineer officer

BBC Bang Goes the Theory demonstrates that NOT all Brazil nuts are radioactive

January 4, 2014 By Rod Adams

The demonstrations in this BBC video are, as the Brits might say, brilliant. Though it has been posted since June, I learned of its existence from the following tweet:

Debunking lack of information on #radiation, the basis of #nuclear science. Very informative video from the BBC… http://t.co/xzsVcYL8OE

— Futuro Nucleare (@futuronucleare) January 4, 2014

I especially liked Dr. Yan’s explanation about why the Brazil nuts he had on his table were not radioactive, even though many nuclear training programs mention them as common sources of naturally occurring radioactive material.

As Dr Yan describes, Brazil nut trees have extensive root networks. They are some of the largest trees in the Amazon rain forest. Because the pollination process is dependent on a uniquely balanced system of specific flowers and large bees, most of the world’s Brazil nuts are harvested from wild trees. In recent years, a surprising 50% of of the nuts in world trade come from Bolivia, not Brazil.

As Dr. Yan explains, when there is naturally occurring radioactive material (NORM) in soil where those roots gather nutrients, some of the material will end up in the nuts. However, the fruit from trees growing in areas where the concentration of uranium, thorium and their daughter products in the soil is low will contain a measurably lower quantity of radioactive material than the fruit from trees in places where the concentrations are higher.

That is completely logical; if there is no NORM to gather, the roots cannot gather it.

The demonstration that Dr. Yan provides in his short video convinced me that the Oak Ridge Associated Universities page titled Brazil Nuts that serves as the source for the Brazil nut Wikipedia page — and probably serves as the source for many radiation training programs — should be revised. It currently makes the following statement:

It is not true, as is sometimes thought, that the high concentration of radium in Brazil nuts is due to elevated levels of the uranium and/or thorium series in the soil in which the tree grows. The accumulation of the radium (and barium) is due to the very extensive root system of the tree.

Theory-to-practice exercises — like taking measurements with a radiation detector — often show that academic theories are not quite correct.


Note: The demonstration also illustrates the value of using accurate radiation detectors in public communications efforts. It helped me decide that one of the first investments of the resources that Atomic Insights subscribers have provided will be the purchase of a portable radiation detector.

Filed Under: Radiation

Avatar

About Rod Adams

Rod Adams is an atomic energy expert with small nuclear plant operating and design experience, now serving as a Managing Partner at Nucleation Capital, an emerging climate-focused fund. Rod, a former submarine Engineer Officer and founder of Adams Atomic Engines, Inc., one of the earliest advanced nuclear ventures, has engaged in technical, strategic, political, historic and financial discussion and analysis of the nuclear industry, its technology and policies for several decades. He is the founder of Atomic Insights and host and producer of The Atomic Show Podcast.

Please click here to subscribe to the Atomic Show RSS feed.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. AvatarLuca Bertagnolio says

    January 4, 2014 at 6:16 PM

    Happy to see that you’ve discovered this nice BBC video from my tweet, Rod! It’s always an honor to be retweeted and now even blogged by “Atomic” Rod!

    Happy Nuke Year!

    Luca Bertagnolio
    aka Futuro Nucleare

  2. AvatarDaniel says

    January 19, 2014 at 9:12 PM

    Fail poor science
    Gamma spectrometry, lead castle and a 2 inch sodium iodide thallium doped scintillation crystal and your find a world of radioactivity in Brazil nuts.
    Small amount of uranium/thorium,radium etc

    • AvatarRod Adams says

      January 20, 2014 at 2:12 AM

      @Daniel

      Not all Brazil nuts have the same level of radioactive material. That is the point. You’re comment is the one that fails.

  3. AvatarAndrew says

    January 20, 2014 at 5:01 AM

    Using a geiger counter on food is poor science as the instrument isn’t suitable for food radioactivity detection unless highly contaminated.

    Run the sample in a lead castle with HPGe or sodium iodide detector and your find NORM.

    Far better to explain NORM and the fact it is everywhere, than as the video presented makes out no radioactivity-when it should state that any Norm is either at background level or below geiger counter detection.

Primary Sidebar

Search Atomic Insights

Follow Atomic Insights

The Atomic Show

Atomic Insights

Recent Posts

Atomic Show #291 – Kalev Kallemets, Fermi Energia

Preliminary lessons available to be learned from Feb 2021 extended cold spell

South Texas Project Unit 1 tripped at 0537 on Feb 15, 2021

Atomic Show #290 – Myrto Tripathi, Voices of Nuclear

Change is in the wind: Commencing a new phase as a Venture Capitalist

  • Home
  • About Atomic Insights
  • Atomic Show
  • Contact
  • Links

Search Atomic Insights

Archives

Copyright © 2021 · Atomic Insights

Terms and Conditions - Privacy Policy