Asbury Park Press – Turn against coal means turning toward nuclear power

ByRod Adams

According to an opinion piece titled Turn against coal leaves nuclear as power option written by James McGovern and posted on the Asbury Park Press (App.com), the recent flood of political decisions against new coal fired power plants indicates that nuclear power is the more palatable energy supply option.

The article points to a big swing in action since May of 2007, when there were as many as 160 new coal fired power plants in various stages of planning. Actions against coal that Mr. McGovern lists include project cancellations in Florida and Texas. It also includes new rules against coal fired power production in California and a move for similar rules in Nevada.

Side comment: According to Mr. McGovern, Florida has a special reason for leading a charge against coal – it is a very low lying state with a great deal of valuable ocean front property. Though Mr. McGovern is right about current concerns, the fact is that Florida’s concerns about coal fired power are not new.

I had insider knowlege on this issue when I was growing up – my Dad was an electrical engineer with Florida Power and Light who spent a good portion of his career as the supervisor of transmission substations. One of the projects that I remember taking up much of his time for a number of years was building a 500 KVA (translated – Really Big) transmission line to bring power from coal fired stations that the company owned in Georgia to south Florida. He often referred to that effort as “coal by wire”. That power line cost the company about a million dollars per mile. The main reason that the company and the Public Utility Commission thought that was a better solution than a locally built power plant was that air quality in the Sunshine State was considered to be too valuable to sully with the emissions from a coal plant. End of Side Comment.

The conclusion that McGovern reaches is one that makes me smile:

There is only one source that can provide large amounts of “base-load” electricity for our nation’s growing economy and population without emitting carbon dioxide or polluting the air — nuclear energy.

Go and read the article. If you feel so inclined, add a comment.

I hope it will be a supportive one, but you need to reach your own conclusions.)

Rod Adams
Rod Adams

Rod Adams is Managing Partner of Nucleation Capital, a venture fund that invests in advanced nuclear, which provides affordable access to this clean energy sector to pronuclear and impact investors. Rod, a former submarine Engineer Officer and founder of Adams Atomic Engines, Inc., which was one of the earliest advanced nuclear ventures, is an atomic energy expert with small nuclear plant operating and design experience. He has engaged in technical, strategic, political, historic and financial analysis of the nuclear industry, its technology, regulation, and policies for several decades through Atomic Insights, both as its primary blogger and as host of The Atomic Show Podcast. Please click here to subscribe to the Atomic Show RSS feed. To join Rod's pronuclear network and receive his occasional newsletter, click here.

Similar Posts

  • Amory Lovins has successfully bamboozled Phil Windley at IT Conversations

    ByRod Adams

    As a podcaster and self confessed IT geek, I subscribe to a newsletter published by Phil Windley titled IT Conversations. It is part of a terrific blog and podcast enterprise of the same name. Phil and his crew have been recording talks, panel discussions and keynote speeches at various IT conferences for several years, providing…

  • Why Am I So Pro-Nuke?

    ByRod Adams

    Last weekend, a friend who regularly publishes diaries on Daily Kos asked permission to reprint my Atomic Insights post titled Charleston (West Virginia) Daily Mail Warns Readers – Proposed Nuclear Plants Could Affect WVa Coal. Knowing that Daily Kos often attracts some passionate commenters, especially when it comes to matters that might challenge their normal…

  • Balanced discussion of California electricity supply

    ByRod Adams

    InsideBayArea.com has published an important article by Sarah Jane Tribble titled A dark horse for alternative energy that gives a good overview of the current discussion that is starting to occur in California about future energy supplies. I highly recommend that you visit the article and enter into the conversation – the site takes comments….

  • Were the Risky Mortgages all on Single Family Homes?

    ByRod Adams

    Again, I have an uncharacteristically off-topic comment/question for your consideration. In nearly every article I have read in the past couple of weeks, the lending/credit crisis in America has been blamed on home mortgages made under less than stringent lending rules and on complex financial instruments designed – ideally – to package those mortgages into…

  • America's Power campaign by "Americans for Balanced Energy Choices" is misleading

    ByRod Adams

    I do not know if any of you have been paying attention to the recent television, print and radio advertising campaign called “America’s Power”. In case you have missed them, you can find some of the videos at www.americaspower.org. Though the commercials a attractive and well produced, and they use some factual material – like…

  • Stark Choice – Coal or Nuclear

    ByRod Adams

    William Tucker has published a column on The American Enterprise web site titled Global Warming Dilemma – Coal or Nuclear?. It is short, succinct and correct. Check it out.