Atomic Show #233 – Innovators discuss advanced reactor development in US

There are a growing number of innovative small companies and a few divisions of larger companies that have recognized that nuclear energy offers solutions to a number of important human challenges. Despite the proclamations by opponents, the Nuclear Renaissance is not any more dead in 2015 than the original Renaissance was dead in 1315.

In the minds of the people who participated in this show, the revival in nuclear energy has only just begun. The ideas and inventions that they envision are almost limitless in potential, even if the first units have not yet received official permission to begin construction.

Providing energy to society is not a fad; it is a business that began about the time that humans discovered how to control fire and will most likely end about the time that human society forgets how to use either fire or fission.

Here is the list of people who participated in the round table about some of the market opportunities, financial challenges, and regulatory obstacles that will be surmounted in the future:

NuScale Power is well down the road towards completing its design and its design certification application to the U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (US NRC). The company’s design traces its roots to a project conducted at Oregon State University called the MASLWR – multi-application small light water reactor. Each NuScale Power Module is a complete 50 MWe generating system, with a natural circulation reactor heat source inside a pressure vessel that is installed in an individual containment and a steam turbine power conversion unit.

The first plant layout that the company is focused on detailing is a 12 module facility that will be able to generate a net power output of 570 MWe. Mike describes NuScale’s design status, tells us a little about the first project and the first customer, and gives us some information about the location of the plant and its estimated completion date.

NuScale plans to file its design certification application during the second half of 2016. It has 600 people working on its team, it is spending about $12 million/month, and it expects to have its first plant operating sometime in 2023. It sees its primary initial market as providing a replacement option for utilities that have decided to retire baseload coal plants instead of updating them to comply with a variety of air quality related regulations.

Terrestrial Energy is at an earlier stage of developing a molten salt, liquid fuel reactor that will transfer its heat to a steam plant secondary. David LeBlanc describes how the company is developing a variety of different models with various electricity production capacities as it seeks its lead customers. It will be focusing initially on the Canadian market.

There are several potential target customer types including northern remote communities, power plants for remote mining and industrial facilities, and process heat consumers. Canon Bryan describes some of the financial issues that are important in the effort to attract private capital to their development project.

Westinghouse Electric Company, the designer of the AP1000 passively safe large light water reactor, developed a smaller version of that popular design to the point where it was within a year of being ready to file a design certification application with the NRC.

Since that is a big step requiring a substantial investment of financial, engineering and managerial resources, the company took a hard look at near term market interest and determined about a year ago that it would put its design on the shelf to wait for a more interested market. Robin Rickman, the Director of Westinghouse’s SMR program describes his company’s strategy, its continued strong interest and participation in small nuclear reactor committees, and its readiness to move forward once an investment decision is made.

Per Peterson is a professor at the University of California Berkeley. He talked about his university’s role in teaching, inspiring innovative thinking and seizing on modern technology opportunities to do what it can to help train a new generation of innovative, capable technical leaders for a rejuvenated nuclear energy industry.

Jacob DeWitte is the CEO of UPower, which has decided to design what they call a micro reactor sized to provide power to remote communities that are not currently served by the electrical power grid. Their 1-2 MW reactors sound incredibly tiny, even compared to the modest sizes of other SMRs finding their way into the market, but 1 MWe generator requires a 1,341 horsepower motor to turn it. That is a fair sized diesel engine, which is the power system that DeWitte sees as his company’s target competition.

We talked about the challenge of getting a license to build and operate a new reactor in the United States, even one that uses traditional light water reactor fuel technology. As the group acknowledged, it is not clear now how the US NRC will succeed in reviewing documents and issuing construction and operating licenses to machines that use entirely different technology like molten salt coolant or liquid fueled reactors.

We also touched on a concept that was discussed during the House Energy and Commerce subcommittee meeting in December, which is the possibility that the government might benefit by hosting prototype or commercial demonstration plants at one or more of its existing nuclear energy laboratory sites. The prime locations for such a cooperative project would be Savannah River Site, Idaho National Laboratory, or Hanford National Laboratory. Other possibilities not mentioned on the show include Oak Ridge or Los Alamos.

I worked hard to improve the sound quality for this show and to ask the guests to make better use of their mute buttons when they were not talking. I think the effort paid off; I’d like to hear your opinion. This topic is also important enough and interesting enough to generate a good deal of discussion, so the comment thread will be open for one week.


ThorCon – Demonstrated Molten Salt Tech Packaged With Modern Construction Techniques

The dearth of real innovation and focused direction from the established companies in the US nuclear industry in the face of rapidly expanding demand for clean energy solutions has stimulated the formation of a number of start-up companies. The leaders of these companies have backgrounds that have taught them to ask “Why not?” when faced […]

Read more »

Putting excitement back into nuclear technology development

Josh Freed, Third Way‘s clean energy vice president, has published a thoughtful, graphically enticing Brookings Essay titled Back to the Future: Advanced Nuclear Energy and the Battle Against Climate Change. It focuses on Leslie Dewan and Mark Massie of Transatomic Power, but it also makes it abundantly clear that those two visionary entrepreneurs are examples […]

Read more »

Atomic Show #229 – Leslie Dewan and Mark Massie, Transatomic Power

On December 1, 2014, I talked with Leslie Dewan and Mark Massie, the co-founders of Transatomic Power, a tiny nuclear reactor design company started up less than 3 years ago. Several weeks ago, I published an article here titled Transatomic Power – Anatomy of Next. That article, as expected, generated a healthy discussion thread. At […]

Read more »

Transatomic Power – Anatomy of Next

Dr. Leslie Dewan is a co-founder and the CEO of Transatomic Power, a venture capital-funded start-up based on research conducted at MIT. Along with Mark Massie, the other co-founder, Dewan is exploring a design that uses a molten salt fuel that enables materials currently classified as “nuclear waste” to provide the heat source for a […]

Read more »

Tour of NuScale control room and test facility

Jose Rod Test Facility

Disclosure: I have a small contract to provide NuScale with advice and energy market information. That work represents less than 5% of my income for 2014. On October 20, 2014, I had the opportunity to visit NuScale’s facilities in Corvallis, OR. Though the company now has offices in three cities, Corvallis, the home of Oregon […]

Read more »

UAMPS stepping forward to serve customers

The established nuclear energy industry has taken a wait-and-see approach to the idea of developing and deploying smaller, simpler fission power stations that can take advantage of the economy of series production. The industry’s trade organization, the Nuclear Energy Institute, has expressed cautious optimism and has engaged in a moderate effort to identify regulatory obstacles […]

Read more »

Prospective customers lining up at NuScale

Each orange circle represents a potential NuScale power plant

A few days ago, Dan Yurman at Neutron Bytes published a blog post that is now titled Flash: NuScale executive says firm may build SMRs at Idaho lab. It was a follow-up to an earlier post in which Dan speculated about the Idaho National Lab’s potential as a good site for a new nuclear power […]

Read more »

Terrestrial Energy – Molten Salt Reactor Designed to Be Commercial Success

There is a growing roster of innovative organizations populated by people who recognize that nuclear technology is still in its infancy. Terrestrial Energy is one of the most promising of those organization because of its combination of problem solving technology, visionary leadership, and strong focus on meeting commercial needs. Nearly all of the commercial nuclear […]

Read more »

Nuclear-Powered Trans-Ocean Shipping – 3rd place in New York Advanced Energy contest

I received an update from Benjamin Haas, the SUNY Maritime student who has been working on nuclear powered ship designs from a complete systems perspective for the past three semesters. He and his team have not just focused on the technical aspects of designing a power plant and a ship that could take full advantage […]

Read more »

Can nuclear energy save Detroit?

Update: (August 2, 2013) – American Atomics is now claiming that there is no site in Detroit that is large enough to house the infrastructure that they are planning to build. Here is a link to their post. It is a pretty incredible claim for a company that currently has no facilities. Supposedly the […]

Read more »