5 Comments

  1. Thanks for having me on the show. I hope your listeners enjoy it and learn a little bit more about Deep Isolation and nuclear waste disposal.

  2. Ultimate disposal of high level waste is irrelevant – the status quo (ISFSI) is adequate – Deep Isolation focuses on a technical solution for a red herring/ distraction/ tangential issue presented by antinuclear opposition. Locating casks or little PWRs deep into bore holes does not improve any figure of merit in waste management or power operations. We really need to elevate HGR’s “practical vs. academic reactor” essay to the status of truism or logical fallacy considering the CONSTANT roll-out of ‘advanced’ nuclear concepts pitched by hobbyists and posers.

  3. @Michael Scarangella

    From a technical perspective, ISFSI is fine.

    It has not convinced enough people to make it adequate from a political point of view. The current payments from the taxpayer funded settlement fund total almost as much as the NRC’s entire budget. There are still plenty of nuclear industry experts pressing for a permanent solution to be implemented – even if it is not heavily used in the foreseeable future.

    No comment regarding little PWRs at the bottom of deep boreholes.

  4. Rod

    You’re welcome. Please check by here periodically during the next couple of weeks to see if there are any comments or questions that you want to address.

  5. In my own little way, I have been using Deep Isolation as a reply when people ask about Nuclear Waste. I have linked their website in replies and encouraged people to consider this. While dry cask storage is fine for now, in many places I have hoped for years to see nuclear deployed, the bore hole solution is better because of the out of sight out of mind effect. It greatly reduces the ability for Anti-Nuclear protestors to grandstand. I also like it because it can be implemented in nearly any location around the world, if not directly on-site then within a short distance. I like the ability to retrieve the rods for possible future use. The simplicity is very appealing and I bet technical solutions would rapidly improve the equipment (tweaking the designs) if there was a large order book and several installations testing the actual conditions.

    Regarding mini PWR’s I would really like the ability to use the slightly used fuel to heat a swimming pool. But then, I am far more relaxed about radiation than most. A pool with a storage cistern to the side about 30 feet down and using convection to move the water would give a long term solution to cold winter days when you want to swim. Well if dreams were horses, beggars would ride. On the other hand, there might be a way to use the decay heat generated in that bore hole…

Comments are closed.

Similar Posts

  • Atomic Show #296 – Julia Pyke, Director of Finance Sizewell C

    Sizewell C is a project to build a 3,200 MWe power station consisting of two EPR units on the site that currently hosts a single large pressurized water reactor (Sizewell B). With the exception of site-specific foundations and structures, the new power station will be a copy of the station currently under construction at Hinkley…

  • Atomic Show #319 – Juliann Edwards, The Nuclear Company

    The Nuclear Company exited a period of operating in “stealth mode” about a month ago. That exit was sufficiently well planned and executed that it is likely that Atomic Insights readers have already heard of the company. The Nuclear Company was incorporated a year ago. Its founding team has been working diligently to build the…

  • Atomic Show #332 – Thomas Jam Pedersen, CEO Copenhagen Atomics

    Copenhagen Atomics is an ambitious Danish company with a bold, potentially world-changing vision. They’re driven by a goal of manufacturing one reactor per day from a high quality, certified factory. If they achieve that goal, they would be adding an additional 37 GW/year of heat to the global energy supply. They want to help make…

  • “Waste issue” is part of antinuclear movement strategy of constipation

    During the 1970s, the antinuclear movement made a collective decision to use “the waste issue” as a weapon to help force the eventual shutdown of the industry. Though the strategy has not succeeded in forcing any plants in the US to shut down, it has prevented a number of plants from being built. Ralph Nader,…

  • Russia continues sustained fast breeder reactor effort

    On June 26, 2014, the 60th anniversary of the start of the 5 MWe Obninsk reactor that was the first reactor in the world to routinely supply electricity to a commercial power grid, Russia started up the latest in a series of sodium-cooled fast reactors, the BN-800. This new nuclear plant is an evolutionary refinement…

  • Atomic Show #203 – Globally distributed atomic conversation

    Attempting to transition away from fossil fuels to an “all renewable” energy system is fraught with cost and reliability challenges. Germany is running into substantial challenges and is burned 5% more lignite – brown coal – in 2012 than it did in 2011. Recently completed studies that including a range of scenarios in Australia and…