6 Comments

  1. An interest in SMRs is all well and good, but will they ever be allowed to be built? I don’t think it would take much research to show that the people who control oil/gas/coal are now running the nuclear power industry, with the help of the NRC and its political comrades. Their agenda is to make nuclear power as expensive as possible so that it offers no advantage cost-wise over carbon fuels.
    It may sound extreme, but what I think the USA needs to be doing is bringing home a goodly number of its armed forces supposedly protecting us from foreign enemies and rounding up large numbers of domestic enemies, who are are far greater threat to the average person in the USA.

  2. @ GaryN

    Of the seventy or more reactors being built right now, only 4 are in the US. Internally, the NRC is doing a fantastic job of stalling any half decent flow.

    The COL cycle was supposed to facilitate the process. It will not.

    But the pressure will come from outside. Americans understand commerce and influence. Secretary Kerry is having a hard time to sell nuclear deals abroad and most of all, keeping a straight face doing so. He has no credibility and can’t Heinz it up.

    Russia on the other hand is signing deals everywhere as the French, Koreans and Japanese are. (Canada is even on the front row for a CANDU encore in Romania)

    So the bottom line is this. It is happening without the US, the nuclear revolution that is. And most of it is under the radar. Nobody is seeing it.

    I cannot help but notice that all proposed nuclear plants forecast TODAY are excluding SMRs that are coming within 2 years from Russia, India, China and Argentina. Even the WNA does not understand the market that will emerge with SMRs.

    Where are the Russian floating SMRs firm orders from Vietnam, Indonesia, China, the Mid East, North Africa in those forecasts?

  3. Your post is a contradiction of itself. On the one hand you criticize the USA for not building large LWR’s right now. On the other hand, game changers called SMR’s are going to be revolutionary and bankrupt the state backed monolithic monster nuclear corporations like Areva and Rosatom primarily selling large LWR’s.

    It can’t possibly be a rosy picture for all the nuclear players.

  4. @starvinglion

    Light water SMRs are not game changers, they are game expanders. Adding them to the mix is like hiring an excellent running back for a team that has a quarterback like Payton Manning or Dan Marino.

    As the US demonstrated throughout the 1960s and into the 1970s, building large numbers of small light water reactors at the same time as building large numbers of large light water reactors is eminently possible and even advantageous. The smaller reactors give parts suppliers sustaining business because they use exactly the same kinds of materials. The enterprise of operating smaller reactors is like the NCAA teams that supply experienced players for the pros.

    Of course, we goofed up a good model by keeping the smaller reactors limited to the US Navy and telling all of the players that most of the information that they learned about those smaller reactors should be kept locked up in a very secret playbook.

    I suspect that other leagues (Russian, Chinese, Korean, French) might learn from our mistake and make a different choice. It is generally good business to offer a larger line of similar products that can serve a wider variety of customer needs.

  5. Rod, it is Peyton Manning, with an E. Walter Payton was with an A.

    As Peyton’s fellow University of Tennessee graduate, I am unable to refrain from pointing that out.

Comments are closed.

Similar Posts

  • Are we finally approaching lift-off for a real Renaissance?

    Obituaries of the “Nuclear Renaissance” have been widespread and frequent in the years since the Great Recession and reactions to the Great Northeast Japanese Earthquake and Tsunami. I’m pretty sure those obits have been premature in declaring the subject to be dead. Last week, I attended the 6th Annual Advanced Reactor Summit and Technology Showcase….

  • U.S. DOE to Follow Industry Lead In Setting Priorities Under Trump

    R. Shane Johnson recently briefed representatives of the U.S. nuclear power industry about the the strategies and programs that the Department of Energy (DOE) is developing to implement the Trump Administration’s vision for nuclear energy. Johnson is the Deputy Assistant Secretary in the DOE’s Office of Nuclear Energy. He’s the senior career civil servant in…

  • NEI Small Reactor Forum Report – Part 1

    The Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI) hosted its biannual Small Reactor Forum on February 25, 2014. The agenda for the one day event included six well-organized sessions with presentations from three small reactor vendors, the industry trade group, the regulatory agency, and several outside observers with a significant interest in the technology from a variety of…

  • SMRs – Why Not Now? Then When?

    I have shamelessly borrowed the title of one of the talks given during the first day of the Nuclear Energy Insider 4th Annual Small Modular Reactor (SMR) Conference as being representative of both the rest of the agenda and the conversations that I had in the hallways during the breaks. For the past five years,…

  • Kairos – Developing advanced nuclear energy in Alameda

    In some ways, Kairos Power has a familiar sounding story. It is a California-based start-up founded by three bright people, all with a tie to Cal Berkeley (UCB). They have decided to turn their grant-funded tech research into a for-profit company. One of the founders, Dr. Per Peterson, is a long established UCB professor with…

  • Broad Interest in Nukes, Especially SMRs, at National Clean Energy Week

    National Clean Energy Week was conceived in June by the Coalition of Responsible Energy Solutions. During July and August the organizers attracted partners, sponsors and speakers. They developed a week-long agenda and located venues for the expo, symposium and panels. Festivities began with a welcome reception for invited guests at Google’s Washington, D.C. office on…