4 Comments

  1. Its difficult to listen to anything come from MIT without thinking about their large and long – since 1990 – involvement in partnering with the coal industry to foster Carbon Capture technology. He’s out of touch with what is going on down on the street. He spoke of the Hyperion and PRISM as if they were emerging designs like LFTRs and TravelingWaves. He doesn’t seem to have learned the lessons tought by the computer revolution: Being huge, expensive, clumsy, and inflexible are rarely advantages in the marketplace. There are at least 8 additional advantages the new small reactors can have over your father’s reactor that have created a whole new nuclear power paradigm.

  2. Rod Adams wrote:
    As Dr. Moniz points out, the United States went through a long period that discouraged some of the smartest students in the country from studying the topics that would be useful to them in becoming nuclear specialists. However, my view is that those minds are no more lost to nuclear energy than is the material stored in those dry casks. We can attract the brilliant engineers who have been designing computers, automobiles, wind turbines and space shuttles for the past 30 years and teach them what they need to know about nuclear in less time than it takes to license the first new units.
    While there are ups and downs in every industry and thus engineering discipline, seldom does that specific field of interest go away entirely. The brightest minds in each field tend to do well through thick and thin, and are usually the most passionate about it. These are the types of minds one would want to have in nuclear, but are the least likely to switch careers. The best one can hope is that some good engineers develop a new-found passion for nuclear energy and make the switch.
    Personnaly, if I were to choose an engineering career now, it would be nuclear. I have done well in my field of electrical engineering for the past 36 years, so at this point I am not looking to make a career switch, other retiring from my full time job to teach beginning electrical engineering courses part time. But if any bright high school student (or parent thereof) should ask, I would certainly recommend nuclear engineering, though I would make sure the student has a passion for it first.

  3. My son is in his Junior year in a nuclear engineering program. Glad to hear you think it’s a good choice (I am a materials scientist myself).

  4. @SteveK9, it will be a good career for him so long as he has a passion for it. I use that word a lot (3 times in my original posting), because it matters a lot. In my case, I was playing around with electrical stuff even before grade school, and never stopped being interested in electronics. I found myself mystified by some of peers in college, who weren’t sure what subject they wanted to be their major.

Comments are closed.

Similar Posts

  • Dr. J Marvin Herndon discusses the georeactor on The Atomic Show

    Dr. J. Marvin Herndon is an independent scientist who has an understandable, logical explanation for the fact that the Earth’s core has generated large quantities of heat for billions of years and for the fact that the Earth has a magnetic field that fluctuates from time to time. The theory is called the georeactor and…

  • Big guns coming out with cost arguments against nuclear power

    In a shocking development, (tongue firmly planted in cheek there) the Wall Street Journal has published a lengthy article by Rebecca Smith discussing the potential that the Nuclear Renaissance might be derailed because of rapidly escalating cost estimates for new nuclear power plants. You can find the article at New Wave of Nuclear Plants Faces…

  • Uranium resources increase by 17% last year

    I have forgotten to mention an article in World Nuclear News from June 2008 that you might want to keep handy as a reference. It is titled Exploration drives uranium resources up 17%. Here is the lede from that article: Current economic uranium resources will last for over 100 years at current consumption rates, while…

  • Better Place – Building Electric Car Momentum With Exciting Concepts

    A friend reminded me that I need to keep an eye on the activities of Better Place – an electric car company with some intriguing ideas and growing momentum. They appear to be signing up additional industrial, financial and government partners for their idea of building and deploying electric cars by focusing on supplying them…