• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About
  • Podcast
  • Archives

Atomic Insights

Atomic energy technology, politics, and perceptions from a nuclear energy insider who served as a US nuclear submarine engineer officer

German Nuclear Utility Stocks Rise; Solar-Related Companies Fall on German Election Results

September 29, 2009 By Rod Adams

MarketWatch.com posted a article titled Nuclear power plant operators rise on center-right win. Here is the article lede:

FRANKFURT (MarketWatch) — German stocks and nuclear power plant operators in particular rose, while solar-related companies dropped Monday after election results indicated that a center-right coalition will be formed.

The September 27 German election provided Angela Merkel with the opportunity to form a coalition with the increasingly popular Free Democratic Party (FDP) rather than the fading Social Democratic Party (SDP). One of the main results of the election will be an effort to abandon the deal that the Social Democratic Party negotiated under the leadership of Gerhard Schroeder. That deal legislated a requirement to shut down the 17 nuclear power plants that currently provide approximately a quarter of Germany’s electrical power well before those power plants have reached the end of their useful service lives.

Here is another interesting quote from the MarketWatch article:

“As a nuclear power plant has very little variable cost, a transfer to other fuel sources or power purchases could have led to a massive decline in cash flows on the magnitude of several billion euros for all four operators, depending on future power prices,” Kleindienst said.

I would have said it differently. Shutting down the operating nuclear plants before the end of their useful service lives would have provided a massive increase in cash flows – on the order of several billion euros – to other fuel and power suppliers. It would have resulted in a decline in cash flow to the current low cost power plant operators. The customers who supply the cash and the taxpayers who provide subsidies for politically popular energy sources would have seen an increase in their cost of living and/or operating their businesses.

Since it costs almost as much to operate a nuclear power plant as it does to own the plant without operating it, the power from an existing plant is “too cheap to meter”. The competition HATES that aspect of nuclear energy systems.

Perhaps that way of stating the case will help people understand why combustion turbine engineers like Mirko Bothien would give the following comment to a UPI reporter:

“The CDU and the FDP bank on cheap energy production to help the German industry. Let’s hope this does not go at the expense of climate protection,” Bothien told UPI in an interview.

The physicist gave his vote to the Greens, “because their party program is the most ambitious when it comes to supporting renewable energy sources.”

No wonder the reporter’s main impression from the interview is that Bothien “is not too excited by the new government’s plans for the future German energy mix.”

I did a little Googling on Mr. Bothien; he produces a lot of published papers on combustion turbines in addition to working for a large Switzerland-based energy company. Suppliers of natural gas or distillate fuel burning turbines would have been beneficiaries of the nuclear plant phaseout. They hoped to gain additional sales volume from the need to replace the electrical power produced by the 17 emission-free nuclear power plants that the government had planned to force to shut down.

Now all of those carefully laid plans are at risk. Darn – got to hate that “cheap energy production” that the CDU and FDP “bank on”. I wonder if Mr. Bothien understands that retaining nuclear power plants in operation cannot possibly be at the “expense of climate protection”? Maybe he should stick to engineering instead of political commentary.

Related Posts

  • Gazprom profiting mightily from German nuclear exit

Filed Under: Uncategorized

About Rod Adams

Rod Adams is an atomic energy expert with small nuclear plant operating and design experience, now serving as a Managing Partner at Nucleation Capital, an emerging climate-focused fund. Rod, a former submarine Engineer Officer and founder of Adams Atomic Engines, Inc., one of the earliest advanced nuclear ventures, has engaged in technical, strategic, political, historic and financial discussion and analysis of the nuclear industry, its technology and policies for several decades. He is the founder of Atomic Insights and host and producer of The Atomic Show Podcast.

Please click here to subscribe to the Atomic Show RSS feed.

Primary Sidebar

Categories

Join Rod’s pronuclear network

Join Rod's pronuclear network by completing this form. Let us know what your specific interests are.

Recent Comments

  • Gordon Mcdowell on Atomic Show #297 – Krusty – The Kilopower reactor that worked
  • Greg White on Atomic Show #297 – Krusty – The Kilopower reactor that worked
  • Gerrit Bruhaug on Atomic Show #297 – Krusty – The Kilopower reactor that worked
  • Eino on Atomic Show #297 – Krusty – The Kilopower reactor that worked
  • David on Atomic Show #297 – Krusty – The Kilopower reactor that worked

Follow Atomic Insights

The Atomic Show

Atomic Insights

Recent Posts

Atomic Show #297 – Krusty – The Kilopower reactor that worked

Nuclear energy growth prospects and secure uranium supplies

Nucleation Capital’s Earth Day in Atherton

Atomic Show #296 – Julia Pyke, Director of Finance Sizewell C

Solar’s dirty secrets: How solar power hurts people and the planet

  • Home
  • About Atomic Insights
  • Atomic Show
  • Contact
  • Links

Search Atomic Insights

Archives

Copyright © 2022 · Atomic Insights

Terms and Conditions - Privacy Policy