2 Comments

  1. Dear Rod, in the other post about terrestrial you ask why sodium chloride isn’t used as the coolant in IMSR.
    The answer is neutronics.
    Moltex uses sodium chloride cause its a fast reactor. In a fast reactor NaCl is just fine.
    Both Na and Cl have some issues with moderated neutrons.
    On the other hand, Li F has excellent neutronics (except for the rarer Lithium isotopes which produces tritium), there’s also Be F which has the positive side effect of neutron multiplication. But Beryllium has health issues in some humans. Hence the famous F Li Be coolant.
    But Terrestrial has yet to announce its initial salt choice. It could even be NaCl, MSRs naturally have so many neutronic advantages over LWRs that they can even use NaCl and live with the somewhat worse neutronics to avoid the Tritium issues with nuclear regulators.

    On the NRC certification, I have every expectation that the NRC won’t be anywhere ready to truly start its certification work in 2019. In fact I expect the first IMSR to be fully operational before the NRC really starts working serious on USA certification for IMSR. Only when the US Congress is shamed that they’re being left behind that they will begin to address the issue. I can only hope the NRC will be forced to provide the same saner approach to SMRs approval that Canada and the UK is.

  2. I hope that Terrestrial has learned the lessons from the Westinghouse bankruptcy: do not compromise the cost competitiveness of your design to obtain NRC certification. If it doesn’t work out, then it doesn’t work out. Of course you will miss out on the US market but that’s much better than bankruptcy.

Comments are closed.

Similar Posts

  • Fission heated gas turbines address MIT Future of Nuclear challenges. Easier, straighter, less costly path

    Addressing Recommendations of MIT Future of Nuclear Energy In a Carbon Constrained World The Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) is a world renowned institution that has produced thousands of highly educated engineers and scientists. It is generously supported by foundations, corporations and governments. In 2003, the MIT Energy Initiative, began publishing a series of reports…

  • Atomic Show #253 – Delivering the Nuclear Promise

    The US nuclear industry has decided that it’s time to take aggressive action to improve its operational efficiency. Leaders have looked hard at the competitive landscape. They’ve clearly recognized that while they produce a valuable, desirable commodity, their production costs are not competitive. Many of them aren’t willing to give up their markets and valuable…

  • Will the U.S cold wave help solve OPEC’s oil inventory hangover?

    Since 2014, investor-focused publications have used terms like ‘awash in oil’, ‘oil glut’ and even ‘world is “drowning” in oil’ to describe the world’s stockpile of already extracted and stored inventory of crude oil. Similar phrases have also been occasionally used to describe inventories of various refined products like gasoline, distillate fuel oil, and kerosene….

  • The most secure place to store Plutonium is inside an operating fission reactor

    Plutonium-239 (Pu-239) is a nuclear fuel source that should play an important role in a sustainable, rapidly growing nuclear power enterprise. It is a natural byproduct that is created inside every fission reactor using uranium fuel. It is fissile with characteristics that are similar to U-235, the fissile material that provides most of today’s nuclear…

  • Mark Cooper is wrong about SMRs and nuclear energy

    Mark Cooper of the Vermont Law School has published another paper in a series critiquing the economics of nuclear energy; this one is titled The Economic Failure of Nuclear Power and the Development of a Low Carbon Electricity Future: Why Small Modular Reactors are Part of the Problem and Not the Solution. It is not…

  • SMRs – Why Not Now? Then When?

    I have shamelessly borrowed the title of one of the talks given during the first day of the Nuclear Energy Insider 4th Annual Small Modular Reactor (SMR) Conference as being representative of both the rest of the agenda and the conversations that I had in the hallways during the breaks. For the past five years,…