7 Comments

  1. This is important to realize that our cells are under constant stress from non-nuclear sources. Thanks Rod. That is a new insight. I updated my blog post The Time Is Right for Discussing Hormesis with this post and some of your other posts. I also added three excellent diagrams that help sort out the radiation levels and there effects on humans.

  2. The problem is that LNT cannot be falsified (or verified) due to the way it is stated, so arguing over it is a waste of time. What is needed is a solid mechanistic model that is not based of vague statistical foundations. The same is true of the radiation hormesis model, at the moment it too develops out of statistical evidence. While both sides can provide a plausible mechanism explaining what they think is happening on the cellular level, hard empirical proof is lacking.

    The debate is becoming somewhat sterile at this point and something needs to be done to break the logjam. But guaranteed, no regulator is going to budge on the counter-evidence tabled to date against LNT.

  3. Ionizing radiation might break a bond in a protein in a human cell, with no long lasting effect. Rarely, this might even cause cell death. Cell death and regrowth occurs naturally in humans, with a characteristic time of a few months, varying by organ. Even more rarely, the ionizing radiation might break a bond in a DNA strand. But DNA is the DOUBLE HELIX, with each protein paired to matching one in the other helix. This redundancy of information allows enzymes to repair broken DNA strands. DNA strand breaks are most commonly due to oxygen ions, not ionizing radiation. (This is the motivation for taking antioxidant vitamins.) The average DNA break and repair rate is about 1 per second PER CELL. There are about 100 trillion cells in the human body.

    During cell division, which is more frequent during growth, the strands are separated, so the redundancy is lost and the repair rate is less. (This is the motivation for more caution for exposure of children and fetuses.)

  4. The LNT assumption has been falsified repeatedly from the time that it was created in the mid-1950s. What has been going on is “willful blindness” of the ever-mounting scientific evidence that contradicts it. The LNT assumption is politicized science designed to create/perpetuate the scare of even the smallest levels of (human-made) radiation. See the commentary, available at: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2939692/pdf/drp-08-378.pdf

  5. @Rick
    Radiation damages far more if it hits at the moment of cell division.
    So stable organism’s (a.o. older persons) are far less vulnerable than organsim’s that are developing fast/

    So Scherb at al showed with exceptional significance that even low level radiation below 0.5mSv/year already enhance the rate of stillbirth, congenital malformations, Down syndrome, peri-natal death, etc.

    The stillbirth rate rising at a staggering ~60% per 1mSv/year rise!
    Btw. this is in line with medical practise to avoid any radiation for pregnant women.

Comments are closed.

Similar Posts

  • Least informed piece on Fukushima yet

    In the weeks leading to the one year anniversary of the demise of the Fukushima Daiichi power station, there have been a number of articles from the usual suspects that seek use the word “Fukushima” as a hypnotic code word that is supposed to result in fear and trembling. Individuals like Karl Grossman, Helen Caldicott…

  • Serious, timely, vital conversation about effects of ionizing radiation

    Recently, the American Nuclear Society and the Health Physics Society hosted an historically important meeting on updating the scientific basis for low dose radiation protection standards. Attendees discussed the effects of low dose radiation, the existing radiation protection construct that has evolved to minimize the impact of those effects, and ways to take advantage of…

  • Radioimmunontherapy (RIT) for follicular lymphoma

    Andrew Schorr, the founder and host of Patient Power, interviewed Dr. Anton Hagenbeek of the University Medical Center Utrecht Netherlands about the result of clinical trials of radioimmunotherapy (RIT) to combat follicular lymphoma. The treatment uses a monoclonal antibody that is covalently bound to Y-90, which is a beta emitter. The monoclonal antibody selectively binds…

  • Culture Imposed by Image Gently Carries Substantial Medical Risks

    I’ve been engaged with the struggle to counter excessive fear of radiation for many years. Since I come at the battle from a perspective of the avoided benefits of nuclear energy production resulting from the imposed fear, I have been focused on that aspect of countering radiation misinformation. My associates and I have often assumed…

  • Let the people of Fukushima go home and get back to work

    By: Ted Rockwell Introduction: This op-ed was originally submitted to the Washington Post. The editors determined that the proper place for it was as a letter to the editor, but of course it is much too detailed and lengthy for that venue. Since the Post did not choose to do anything with it, Ted gave…

  • NRC calls off expensive search for witches

    On September 8, 2015, the NRC announced that it would stop funding the National Academy of Sciences’s (NAS) five-year-long, multimillion dollar effort to create a method that could be used to study whether or not populations that are exposed to radiation doses that are a tiny fraction of average background radiation related to proximity to…