• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About
  • Podcast
  • Archives

Atomic Insights

Atomic energy technology, politics, and perceptions from a nuclear energy insider who served as a US nuclear submarine engineer officer

Strange numbers from a normally credible source

March 18, 2007 By Rod Adams

Matthew Simmons is an investment banker who has long been associated with the idea that the era of cheap oil is coming to an end. His analysis is based on the work of M. Hubbert King and other oil exploration experts who have recognized the idea that the world has a finite quantity of oil available and that we are nearing the point where we have consumed about half of the amount that we will ever be able to consume. The shorthand for that concept is called “Peak Oil”.

The reason for this post is to express some disappointment in the quality of Mr. Simmons’s research – at least as indicated by a single table included in a recent talk that he gave to Peabody Coal titled “Sunrise in Coal Fields: Coal’s Role in a Peak Oil World.” You can find a link to a PDF version of the talk at http://www.simmonsco-intl.com/research.aspx?Type=msspeeches

Page 11 of the talk is titled “Backing Out Natural Gas Kilowatt’s Creates Enormous Coal Use Growth”. The slide has a table titled “2005 Electricity Net Generation(Million KW Hours)”. Here are the numbers from that table:

Table from Simmons March 3, 2007 talk to Peabody

I found the table strange because I am a numbers geek and I happen to know the Energy Information Agency figures for electricity production figures for recent years in the US reasonably accurately. The table did not jive with my remembered figures so I went to the source and looked them up.

In case you have never visited the site – I highly recommend the US Energy Information Agency’s web site as a source for historical energy information. (I normally discount that group’s ability to predict anything but the very near term, but they are pretty competent statistics gatherers.)

The applicable table in this case is titled “Net Generation by Energy Source by Type of Producer” and it is posted at:
http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/electricity/epa/epat1p1.html
It is a lengthy table with data going back a number of years, but I have extracted the 2005 numbers for you.

EIA 2005 Electricity Source totals

Notice the difference? I have asked the point of contact listed on Mr. Simmons’s presentation if he can clarify why the coal and total electricity generation numbers are nearly exactly right, but that the rest of the numbers in the table are off by quite a large fraction.

Wonder if I’ll get a response. Any speculation on the reasons for this apparent lack of fact checking attention to detail?

Filed Under: Uncategorized

About Rod Adams

Rod Adams is an atomic energy expert with small nuclear plant operating and design experience, now serving as a Managing Partner at Nucleation Capital, an emerging climate-focused fund. Rod, a former submarine Engineer Officer and founder of Adams Atomic Engines, Inc., one of the earliest advanced nuclear ventures, has engaged in technical, strategic, political, historic and financial discussion and analysis of the nuclear industry, its technology and policies for several decades. He is the founder of Atomic Insights and host and producer of The Atomic Show Podcast.

Please click here to subscribe to the Atomic Show RSS feed.

Primary Sidebar

Categories

Join Rod’s pronuclear network

Join Rod's pronuclear network by completing this form. Let us know what your specific interests are.

Recent Comments

  • David on Atomic Show #297 – Krusty – The Kilopower reactor that worked
  • Rod Adams on Atomic Show #297 – Krusty – The Kilopower reactor that worked
  • David on Atomic Show #297 – Krusty – The Kilopower reactor that worked
  • Rod Adams on Atomic Show #297 – Krusty – The Kilopower reactor that worked
  • paul wick on Atomic Show #297 – Krusty – The Kilopower reactor that worked

Follow Atomic Insights

The Atomic Show

Atomic Insights

Recent Posts

Atomic Show #297 – Krusty – The Kilopower reactor that worked

Nuclear energy growth prospects and secure uranium supplies

Nucleation Capital’s Earth Day in Atherton

Atomic Show #296 – Julia Pyke, Director of Finance Sizewell C

Solar’s dirty secrets: How solar power hurts people and the planet

  • Home
  • About Atomic Insights
  • Atomic Show
  • Contact
  • Links

Search Atomic Insights

Archives

Copyright © 2022 · Atomic Insights

Terms and Conditions - Privacy Policy